No. Side-by-side houses routinely read far apart, because foundation type, cracks, sump plumbing, HVAC behavior, and the soil pocket under each slab all differ. The EPA's position is blunt: every home should be tested, whatever the neighbors found.
More detail
Central Indiana streets make the point vividly. In Noblesville or Plainfield, a courthouse-era house on a stone cellar can sit two doors from a 2005 build on drain tile and a sump; in Greenwood, the same floor plan repeats down the block but one slab got gravel fill and another got compacted spoil. Glacial till itself is lumpy at house scale, with sand lenses and clay pockets that change how gas moves over a few dozen feet. The pattern holds in the data: Zone 1 counties are full of low readings, and Zone 2 counties produce 10-plus results every year, which is exactly why the EPA says zone maps must not substitute for testing. A screening kit costs $15 to $30 and one week of patience. The county data page shows the spread behind every average.