A black, organic-rich Devonian-Mississippian shale that concentrates uranium. It subcrops beneath northwest and west-central Marion County, and the glaciers that crossed Indiana ground it into the till that now sits under much of the metro's housing.
More detail
Black shales hold uranium because the oxygen-poor mud they formed in pulled dissolved uranium out of ancient seawater, and uranium's decay chain ends up at radium and then radon. Central Indiana gets the effect twice. Houses near the subcrop sit close to the source rock itself, and houses across the rest of the region sit on Wisconsin-age glacial till that carries shale fragments and shale-derived minerals wherever the ice dragged them, which is why high tests show up in Hancock and Hamilton county subdivisions nowhere near the subcrop line. Indiana Academy of Science work on Indianapolis-area radon and the USGS geologic radon assessment for the region both document the pattern. The full story, with maps and sources, is in the geology post.