Sealing alone rarely gets a high house under 4 pCi/L. The EPA treats it as a supporting measure, not a standalone fix, because soil gas follows pressure, and pressure finds whichever opening the caulk gun missed.
More detail
The arithmetic is unforgiving: a foundation has far more entry area than anyone can see, block cores, the full run of the floor-wall joint, hairline cracks under finished floors, the soil under a crawl, and sealing the visible 10 percent leaves the hidden 90 percent carrying the same pressure difference. That is why sealing without suction tends to disappoint, and why sealing with suction matters so much: once a fan holds the sub-slab at lower pressure, closing the big openings keeps the fan from wasting its pull on basement air and lets a smaller, quieter fan do the job. So the answer is sequencing, not either-or. Houses that test modestly elevated sometimes try sealing plus a retest first, and that is a legitimate experiment if expectations are calibrated. Houses at 6 or 8 pCi/L should go straight to an active system.